S22 reasoning: Marriage, divorce and remarriage
Reasoning steps: Marriage, divorce and remarriage
Verdicts: S22 · Marriage, divorce and remarriage. Method: conventions, scoring and proximity eras. Scripture is the primary measure; fathers are weighed by era (Era I to c. 150 = 1.0, II = 0.8, III = 0.6, IV = 0.4).
S22.1: Divorce for adultery, and remarriage of the innocent party
Step S22.1.1: Scripture
Matt 19:9: ‘whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality (μὴ ἐπὶ πορνείᾳ), and marries another, commits adultery’; Matt 5:32 likewise; Mark 10:11–12 and Luke 16:18 give no exception; 1 Cor 7:15: if the unbeliever departs, ’the brother or sister is not enslaved’. In first-century Jewish usage a lawful divorce normally freed the parties to remarry, which favours reading the exception as covering remarriage; the absolute sayings in Mark and Luke and Rom 7:3 keep the point disputed.
Step S22.1.2: Patristic evidence
Hermas (Era I): the husband ‘should put her away, and remain by himself’. Athenagoras (Era II): even ‘a second marriage is only a specious adultery’. Origen (Era II–III) reports that ‘some even of the rulers of the church have permitted a woman to marry, even when her husband was living, doing contrary to what was written’. Basil (Era III): ’the man who has been abandoned is pardonable’. Augustine (Era III): marriage is not to be severed and the divorced are not to be ‘joined to another’. Sources: hermas-s22-s1 · origen-s22-s1 · basil-s22-s1 · augustine-s22-s1.
Step S22.1.3: Weighing decision
Era I–II allow separation for adultery but not remarriage; Origen shows remarriage was already practised by some bishops and judged contrary to Scripture. Era III divides: Basil tolerates a deserted husband’s remarriage as ‘pardonable’; Augustine forbids remarriage while the spouse lives. Verdict: the early consensus is separation without remarriage; Eastern pastoral tolerance appears in Era III; Scripture’s exception clause probably permits more than the fathers allowed.
- Confidence: Medium.
Step S22.1.4: Source-proximity weighing
- Scripture (benchmark): Matt 5:32 and 19:9 allow divorce for πορνεία and, read in their Jewish setting, probably remarriage; 1 Cor 7:15 frees the deserted believer; Mark 10 and Luke 16 state the rule without the exception. (Scripture confidence: medium)
- Assessment: Here Scripture and the earliest fathers diverge: the fathers are stricter than the most natural reading of Matthew’s exception. Traditions that forbid remarriage fit Era I–II; those allowing the innocent party to remarry fit Scripture better.
S22.2: Is marriage a sacrament?
Step S22.2.1: Scripture
‘This mystery (μυστήριον; Vulgate sacramentum) is profound, and I am saying that it refers to Christ and the church’ (Eph 5:32). Marriage is a creation ordinance (Gen 2:24; Matt 19:4–6) that images Christ and the church; Scripture does not present it as a rite instituted by Christ to give grace.
Step S22.2.2: Patristic evidence
Tertullian (Era II–III): the marriage ‘which the Church cements, and the oblation confirms, and the benediction signs and seals’. Augustine (Era III): one of marriage’s goods is ’the Sacrament, that marriage be not severed’. Sources: tertullian-s22-s1 · augustine-s22-s2.
Step S22.2.3: Weighing decision
Era II–III show church blessing of marriage and call its bond a sacramentum, but no one before 750 counts sacraments as seven; that list is 12th-century. Verdict: marriage is a holy, church-blessed bond and a ‘sacrament’ in Augustine’s sense (a sacred, indissoluble sign) from Era III; its status as one of seven grace-giving sacraments is a later definition.
- Confidence: Medium.
Step S22.2.4: Source-proximity weighing
- Scripture (benchmark): Eph 5:32 calls the Christ–church union a ‘mystery’ imaged by marriage; marriage is a creation ordinance, not a rite instituted by Christ. (Scripture confidence: medium)
- Assessment: The fathers’ ‘sacrament’ language supports a sacred view of marriage without the later seven-sacrament definition; Protestant denials fit Scripture’s creation-ordinance framing.
S22.3: Does wilful desertion dissolve a marriage?
Step S22.3.1: Scripture
1 Cor 7:15 (LSB): ‘Yet if the unbelieving one leaves, let him leave. The brother or the sister is not enslaved in such cases, but God has called us to peace.’ Paul has just repeated the Lord’s rule that a wife who leaves ‘must remain unmarried, or else be reconciled’ (7:11), and later says ‘A wife is bound (δέδεται) as long as her husband lives’ (7:39). Against that, ’not enslaved’ (οὐ δεδούλωται, perfect: ‘has not been and is not bound’) most naturally means the deserted believer is released from the bond, and so free to marry. Paul does not say ‘may remarry’ outright, and he speaks only of desertion by an unbeliever.
Step S22.3.2: Patristic evidence
No Era I–II writer addresses desertion directly. Ambrosiaster (Rome, c. 375, Era III), in our rendering of the Latin: ‘it is no sin for one who is sent away for God’s sake to join himself to another. For the insult to the Creator dissolves the right of marriage for the one who is left.’ Basil (Era III), Letter 188 canon 9: ’the man who has been abandoned is pardonable, and the woman who lives with such a man is not condemned.’ Chrysostom (Era III): if the unbeliever demands idolatry, ‘it were better the marriage were annulled’; ‘it is better to separate’; he does not discuss remarriage. Augustine (Era III) treats unbelief as a kind of ‘fornication’ that allows separation, but holds that neither spouse may ’take another while the wife is living whom he has put away’. Sources: ambrosiaster-s22x-s1 · chrysostom-s22x-s1 · augustine-s22x-s1 · basil-s22-s1.
Step S22.3.3: Weighing decision
All the evidence is Era III and it divides. Ambrosiaster (followed later by Western canon law) and Basil allow the deserted party a new marriage; Augustine allows separation only; Chrysostom allows separation and leaves remarriage open. Verdict: a real split in the 4th century, with no earlier witness; the fathers who comment on 1 Cor 7:15 itself (Ambrosiaster, Chrysostom) read it as releasing the believer, but only Ambrosiaster says so for remarriage.
- Confidence: Low.
Step S22.3.4: Source-proximity weighing
- Scripture (benchmark): 1 Cor 7:15 releases the believer deserted by an unbelieving spouse; whether ’not enslaved’ includes freedom to remarry is the most natural reading but is not stated. (Scripture confidence: low)
- Assessment: Traditions that let the deserted believer remarry follow the most natural reading of Paul and Ambrosiaster; those that forbid it follow Augustine. Extending the ground from an unbelieving spouse to any deserter is an inference beyond the text.
Post-750 development by tradition
Catholic
Trent XXIV (1563): marriage a sacrament and indissoluble; separation allowed.
- S22.1 (fathers 4/4; Scripture 2/4): Trent XXIV canon 7 anathematizes the claim that the bond can be ‘dissolved on account of the adultery of one of the married parties’ or that the innocent party may remarry (verified).
- S22.2 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 2/4): Trent XXIV canon 1: matrimony is ’truly and properly one of the seven sacraments of the evangelic law … instituted by Christ’ and confers grace (verified).
- S22.3 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 3/4): Trent XXIV canon 5 anathematizes the claim that ‘on account of heresy, or irksome cohabitation, or the affected absence of one of the parties, the bond of matrimony may be dissolved’ (verified); canon law keeps the ‘Pauline privilege’, under which a marriage of two unbaptized persons ‘is dissolved’ in favour of the convert who remarries, ‘provided that the non-baptized party departs’ (CIC 1983 can. 1143, verified).
Orthodox
Second and third marriages by economy, with a penitential rite.
- S22.1 (fathers 2/4; Scripture 2/4): OCA Holy Synod, ‘On Marriage’: second and third marriages ‘are tolerated as condescension to human frailty and weakness, while fourth marriages are totally forbidden’; the ‘Order of Second Marriage’ is used (verified); grounds go beyond adultery.
- S22.2 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 2/4): Dositheus, decree 15: ’there are in the Church Evangelical Mysteries … and that they are seven’, matrimony among them (verified).
- S22.3 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not assessed: no classic Orthodox text naming desertion as a ground was located; Trullo canon 87 repeats Basil’s leniency toward a deserted spouse’s new marriage but is not a ruling on dissolving the bond.
Oriental Orthodox
Coptic discipline: divorce for adultery only (since 1944, restated 2008).
- S22.1 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 3/4): Coptic Church: ’no divorce has been permitted within the Coptic community except in cases of adultery’ since 1944 (Pope Shenouda III, 2010, Coptic Diocese of Los Angeles report, verified); remarriage of the innocent party was not separately verified.
- S22.2 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 2/4): Coptic Church (Bishop Mettaous): the seven sacraments include the ‘Sacrament of Matrimony’ (verified).
- S22.3 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not assessed: no Oriental Orthodox text on desertion was located; the Coptic report cited for S22.1 names adultery only.
Lutheran
Treatise on the Power and Primacy 78.
- S22.1 (fathers 1/4; Scripture 4/4): Treatise on the Power and Primacy of the Pope: ‘Unjust also is the tradition which forbids an innocent person to marry after divorce’ (verified).
- S22.2 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not assessed: the Lutheran statement on marriage as a sacrament (Apology XIII) was not located in the texts checked.
- S22.3 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not assessed: the Treatise’s ‘innocent person’ clause does not name desertion, and the Book of Concord has no desertion article.
Anglican
Canon 107 (1604); the 1662 vow ’till death us do part’.
- S22.1 (fathers 4/4; Scripture 2/4): Canons of 1604, canon 107: those separated ‘shall live chastely and continently, neither shall they, during each other’s life, contract matrimony with any other person’ (verified as quoted in Hansard, 3 June 1830).
- S22.2 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 4/4): Art. XXV: Matrimony is among ’those five commonly called Sacraments’ that ‘are not to be counted for Sacraments of the Gospel’, being ‘states of life allowed in the Scriptures’ (verified).
- S22.3 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 2/4): Canons of 1604, canon 107: the separated ‘shall live chastely and continently, neither shall they, during each other’s life, contract matrimony with any other person’ (verified as quoted in Hansard); no exception for desertion.
Presbyterian
WCF XXIV.5–6.
- S22.1 (fathers 1/4; Scripture 4/4): WCF XXIV.5–6: after adultery the innocent party may ‘sue out a divorce: and, after the divorce, to marry another’; also ‘wilful desertion as can no way be remedied’ (verified).
- S22.2 (fathers 2/4; Scripture 4/4): WCF XXVII.4: ‘There be only two sacraments ordained by Christ our Lord in the Gospel’ (verified).
- S22.3 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 4/4): WCF XXIV.6: ’nothing but adultery, or such willful desertion as can no way be remedied by the church, or civil magistrate, is cause sufficient of dissolving the bond of marriage’, with ‘a public and orderly course of proceeding’ (verified, OPC text).
Reformed Baptist
1689 ch. 25 (silent).
- S22.1 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not assessed: 1689 ch. 25 has only four paragraphs and omits the WCF divorce paragraphs, so no position is stated (verified).
- S22.2 (fathers 2/4; Scripture 4/4): 1689 28.1: only baptism and the Lord’s Supper are ‘ordinances of positive and sovereign institution’ (verified).
- S22.3 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not assessed: 1689 ch. 25 omits the WCF divorce paragraphs, including the desertion clause (verified).
General Baptist
Orthodox Creed art. 47.
- S22.1 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not addressed: Orthodox Creed (1679) art. XLVII (Of Marriage) treats monogamy, consent and degrees, with no divorce clause (verified).
- S22.2 (fathers 2/4; Scripture 4/4): Orthodox Creed (1679) art. XXVII: ‘These two Sacraments, (viz.) Baptism, and the Lord’s Supper, are Ordinances of Positive, Sovereign, and holy Institution’ (verified, reformedontheweb.com transcription).
- S22.3 (fathers n/a/4; Scripture n/a/4): Not addressed: Orthodox Creed (1679) art. XLVII has no divorce clause (verified).
Anabaptist
Dordrecht XII.
- S22.1 (fathers 1/4; Scripture 4/4): Menno Simons, Instruction on Excommunication: ‘divorce is not allowed by the Scripture only by reason of adultery’ (CCEL, verified); Wismar Resolutions (1554), as quoted in GAMEO ‘Divorce and Remarriage’: ‘In cases of deliberate adultery, the innocent party may be free to remarry after consulting with the congregation’ (reputable scholarship).
- S22.2 (fathers 2/4; Scripture 4/4): Dordrecht XII: ’the state of matrimony’, instituted ‘in Paradise’, without sacramental language (verified).
- S22.3 (fathers 3/4; Scripture 2/4): Menno Simons, Instruction on Excommunication: ‘divorce is not allowed by the Scripture only by reason of adultery’ (CCEL, verified), which leaves no desertion ground.