Skip to content

Hilary of Poitiers: source notes

Hilary of Poitiers: source notes

Works: Commentary on Matthew. Edition/translation: Latin: SC 254 (Doignon), i.200; PL 9:961A (per D. H. Williams, JEH 57 (2006), 649–667).

Back to justification · reasoning · conventions

S1: Comm. Matt. 8.6 (on Matt 9:2–3)

  • Source: https://gloss-e.irht.cnrs.fr/php/editions_chapitre.php?chapitre=55_9&id=catena&numLivre=55 (IRHT scholarly edition of the Glossa catena, quoting Hilary)
  • Text: “Movet scribas remissum ab homine peccatum … et remissum est ab eo quod lex laxare non poterat; fides enim sola iustificat.” (“the Law could not release it; for faith alone justifies”). The IRHT catena has the same wording: “que lex laxare non poterat fides enim sola iustificat”.
  • Context: Hilary is commenting on the healing of the paralytic. Williams notes that Hilary is explaining how the Gentiles share in the covenant, not setting out a full soteriology. The catena is an independent scholarly witness to the wording.
  • Bears on: Q2
  • Status: secondary-attested (two independent witnesses; SC 254 not inspected)

Doctrine S20X

See S20X reasoning.

S20X S1: On the Trinity X.23, 47

  • Source: https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/330210.htm (public-domain English translation)
  • Text: “He had a body to suffer, and He suffered: but He had not a nature which could feel pain. … He bore our sins, that is, He assumed our body of sin … So too He felt pain for us, but not with our senses.”
  • Context: Hilary (c. 360) argues that Christ’s body suffered the violence of the passion without its pain; in §§36–43 he reads ‘sorrowful unto death’ as grief for the apostles (‘It is not, therefore, for Himself that He is sorrowful’), though §55 admits ‘we cannot doubt that Jesus Christ truly wept’.
  • Bears on: S20.3
  • Status: verified (English)